Maus as a book worked excellent for me. If I had to wait each week, month, or whatever length of time to be able to read the next strip of comic, I would not be as thrilled. To be able to knock out the whole book in one day really kept me curious to figure out what was going on. I really enjoyed it as a comic as well. It was less reading and more viewing which is good to have after finishing Into the Wild. Yes, there is a lot of imagery and text that is excluded being a book, but the comic was very interesting. I feel like it is able to reach out to a larger audience being a comic.
The only parts I think that would work as a comic are the exerpts where the creator is talking with his family and the viewing of the creator’s comic of his mother. These two scenarios would be difficult to be interesting and also to be easily fitted into a novel. The parts of the comic that deal with the author trying to glean knowledge from his father really brings the comic to reality as I know it. Then diving into what his father’s personal narrative of the Holocaust prepares the reader for the tragedy about to commence. The other part of the comic that would be difficult to express in a novel is the author’s representation of his comic about his mother’s death. It would be very difficult to describe it without actually presenting it.
If I were to choose any book to be a comic, it would be The Lord of the Rings trilogy. Granted, it would be a massive, I mean massive, comic, but it would be an excellant read. It would give the long, descriptive Tolkien much more ground to reach out to readers. It would strengthen the interest because you could see with your own eyes how the story is unfolding. Instead of just being a novel, a comic version of The Lord of the Rings would capture all of the ideas Tolkien presents and show the reader just how it would look. But now that I think about it, the movies of the LOTR already do exactly what I just mentioned and more. The movies did an amazing job capturing the detail and storyline of how wonderful this book really is. The only difference is that there would be very few parts of the movie to read, only when there is something to be translated. But this is exactly what our society feeds itself upon: media. It is so much easier to sit down and watch hours worth of movies than it is to spend even more time reading a book. In a way media really steals a lot of value that books encompass. A comic is a good mediator between a movie and a book. It has words and images. It plays off of the imagery of the film, but the ideas of a book. So after writing this blog, I decided a comic of the LOTR would be an excellent mediator between the film and the books.
